"On one occasion, I went to a children's day fair and found myself sitting next to another politician. He was grasping a pile of 100 baht notes to hand out to the children, whereas I had come with nothing. How could I compete with that?"
Chutiphong Pipoppinyo was a member of the "idealistic tide" of idealistic young candidates who surprised Thailand in the 2023 election by winning more seats for the forward-thinking movement than any rival party.
However, in the latest election, he lost his seat in his electoral district of Rayong to a opponent from an long-standing political dynasty which has traditionally controlled positions of power there.
"In 2023 we were similar to a gale that swept through and the other parties weren't ready to counter. They assumed I was just a unknown candidate. The surge of support for Move Forward in the last phase of that election truly encouraged voters to try change."
Now renamed the People's Party, their aspirations that they would build upon their earlier showing were dashed on the rocks of traditional clientelist systems which have controlled provincial politics in Thailand during its contemporary era.
The outcomes are still not official, and a several election issues are being investigated, but that won't change the final picture: a sharp drop of more than 20% in the number of seats won by the People's Party, and a notable surge by the conservative Bhumjaithai party, increasing its number of seats from 71 in 2023 to an projected 193 in the 500-seat parliament now.
'They did not speak with me after that'
After gaining his seat in 2023, Chutiphong dedicated himself to his role as MP, visiting his electoral area hoping to tackle the problems of his constituents. But he quickly encountered resistance from those working for the long-standing political operators. Furthermore, he found he was pressured to make substantial contributions, from resources he did not have.
"I was invited to a women's rights event - a frequent gathering for the residents to participate in and socialize. But they informed me if I wished to come, I must give 25,000 baht. I explained I did not possess that money. They were very unhappy about that and claimed I was unfeeling. I asked them if there was something else I could contribute. But they ignored me afterwards."
What he had confronted was a entrenched framework of patronage run by a single family.
Rayong is best known as a component of the Eastern Economic Corridor, Thailand's biggest industrial zone, containing many of the factories which power its export-dependent economy. This has attracted laborers from elsewhere from across the country, and also led to an city-dwelling professionals which is more open to the change-oriented platforms of the progressive movement.
In 2023, Move Forward swept all five electoral districts there.
But a significant portion of Rayong is still countryside, the domain of agricultural workers and fruit growers. This is notably the case in District 4, where Chutipong claimed his seat. He is a area resident, but lived a number of years residing in California. The province has for many years been controlled by a prominent local household, the Pitutecha family. This is what is known in Thailand as "Baan Yai" – large household – politics, and throughout the country it is the manner provincial control has always been maintained.
Pitutechas run extensive sections of the regional authority.
Piya 'Chang' Pitutecha, the present family head, is the selected chief of the Provincial Administration Organisation (PAO), a hugely influential post as the PAO manages the bulk of public funds in Rayong.
Prior to 2023, Pitutechas had consistently been included in the MPs elected to parliament, with one serving as the deputy health minister in Bangkok.
Similar to other "Baan Yai" families they have no particular allegiance – historically they have represented several political parties. They are also prominent in the regional commercial sector, and, in contrast to Chutipong, have ample funds to hand out. It was virtually impossible for the rookie MP to challenge.
The "Big House" rely on vast systems of local agents - local people who know their neighbourhoods, and who mobilise voters to support their candidate. And while it is formally forbidden, they also hand out money during and after elections. They have always been critical to the victory of provincial hopefuls, and as a novel, largely city-based party, the People's Party had no access to them.
"So I changed my tactics," says Chutipong. "I declared that I would try to resolve all issues immediately. If your water is not flowing, your electricity is off, your road has damage, I would assist."
"But the residents who sought my help then faced intimidation from the local machine. Some got attacked in the village's messaging app or through the PA system in the village. They were blamed of bringing me - a stranger they said - into the area."
"On occasions when I tried to inspect factories after receiving some reports about contamination, I encountered a backlash from the community because they had been receiving envelopes from these factories."
By the time of the latest election cycle, the Pitutechas had adjusted following their defeat in the previous election.
In Districts 3 and 4, they fielded younger members of the family, more qualified and with a diminished old-guard reputation than the older generation. In District 3 they stood under the Democrat party, historically their favored political partner, but in District 4, thirty-four-year-old Chatchai Pitutecha stood under Prime Minister Anutin Charvirakul's Bhumjaithai party, renowned for its substantial resources and its expertise in winning "Baan Yai" for his side.
Chutipong was outgunned.
The Pitutechas recaptured both seats back from the People's Party, while the reformists kept three seats in Rayong.
"They could have welcomed me if I had given them money, but I could not do that indefinitely due to my limited resources. I had to determine whether I would be the representative they expected, or if I would keep my ideals and see if the constituents would